The Boys

The next day, Natsu called Gray and Gajeel saying that he has an idea... He gets in a 6-way call with Gray, Lucy, Gajeel, Juvia and Levy. They're all confused at the call, but Natsu starts to speak saying, "So hi everyone. You may have noticed that are three couples in the call right now, so i'm sure you're suspicious. Well, I have a question. Raise your hand, if you want sex." Every single one of them raise their hand and Natsu smiles. He continues by saying, "So I see that everyone is pretty horny. I would like to propose an idea: how about we have an orgy, but switch up the couples. We can experience something new and also have the sexual release we need. Agree?" Everyone is shocked at the idea coming from Natsu, except for Lucy. She knew how much he liked to fuck, and she matched him in that urge too. Everyone was hesitant, but decided to agree. It might be fun. So, everyone comes over to Natsu's house to decide the new couples. They all sit down in the living room and Natsu asks, "So, the system is: one person is put on the table and whoever wants them, raises their hand. The same sex is allowed, to make it more spicy. If there's more than one person, then we rock paper scissors to see who gets the person. Also it has to be someone who isn't already in a couple. Understood?" Everyone nods and Natsu says, "Very good. Now, who's up for the chop?" The first person to raise their hand was Lucy. Natsu slightly raises his eyebrow, but decides it's fine. When asked who wants Lucy, three people raise their hand. Gray, Gajeel and Juvia. Gray is alarmed when Juvia raises her hand, but decides to go along with it. They all rock-paper-scissors and Gajeel wins. He grins and claims Lucy by picking her up. Lucy blushes at the sudden action and is glad for Gajeel. She never confessed, but she always thought Gajeel was hot. He was more masculine than Natsu and seemed more alpha-like. She couldn't wait to lash out. After Lucy, Levi came up and all 3 of them raised their hands. They fought and finally Juvia won. She looked happy and Levi smiled innocently. Levi was always a little bi-curious and Juvia seemed fun. She always dressed pretty nicely and seemed to like it slow, just like Levy. The only 2 that were left, were Gray and Natsu. They both growled at each other, but deep down wanted each other badly. Natsu remembers seeing Gray's dick and was thirsty for it. Gray always eyed Natsu's bubble butt and couldn't wait for a good anal session. 

Thankfully, Natsu's house had just enough bedrooms to where they all could get an individual room. They were all excited and wanted to let it rip.

(The next 3 chapters will be each of their experiences, in the order of Gajeel/Lucy (L, G), Juvia/Levy (J, Lv) and Gray/Natsu (Gr, N).